So it's impossible to read any green news lately and not come across Colin and Michelle Beavan, the NY couple who have pledged to live for a year with as little impact on the planet as possible. Or, as the NY Times put it, a year "without toilet paper." Pretty much says it all, doesn't it?
Although living without food that comes in packages and forgoing dining out in the name of eco-consciousness is interesting, I found myself drawn mostly to how this change is affecting the couple's two year old daughter, Isabella. While little is mentioned on how she's handling the switch to a home-steading life, the couple do relay an anecdote in which--breaking their vow against shopping--they relent and buy Isabella a birthday present. The prize? A pair of ballet slippers picked up for a buck. When I first read that I felt sorry for Isabella. I'm all for thrift store purchases, but a lone pair of slippers?
But after giving it some thought, I found I actually admired the Beavans. It's no easy task, deciding what and how much to buy a child. I know I'm always trying to strike that magical balance between buying things that foster Lu's development and not wanting to buy too much of anything. I want my daughter to possess an imagination that flourishes as a consequence of time spent in her own mind instead of someone else's; a curious intellect derived from examining the natural world instead of an artificial one. Still, I struggle. Who doesn't walk past the toy store and want to nab that cute new Uglydoll?
When I'm good at sticking to my guns, I learn to improvise: a drum is made from an old coffee can; a shaker from dried beans and a carton. When I'm bad, well, that's when Lu walks out of the local bookstore with a new book plucked from the shelf on a whim. Books, I tell myself, are good for her development. But isn't there a danger there, too, with over-consumption? Lofty ambitions aside, collecting is collecting.
I can't help but wonder: how do we provide our children with what they need while ensuring we don't create false needs in the process? One way I try and catch myself when I think I'm over-indulging Lu, materially or otherwise, is to imagine we're living a very different life. One where we don't have extra money to spend on so many toys, books, clothes. One where I'm so busy making three meals from scratch that I am truly my daughter's mother and not her all-day playmate.
Maybe the Beavans are onto something with their $1 ballet slippers.
Hm...maybe. But I still want my toilet paper!
What do you think? I'd love to hear thoughts on how you're raising children who aren't spoiled or spoiling the planet. For the NY Times article "The Year Without Toilet Paper," click here: No Impact. Free registration required.





